Successive percentage changes
During March, the number of plants in a nursery increased by p%. During April, the number of plants decreased by (p − 5)% of the number present at the end of March. At the end of April, the nursery had 2% more plants than it had at the beginning of March. If p > 5, what is the value of p?
By hand
- Let N be the initial number of plants. After March, the number is N(1 + p/100).
- After April, the number is N(1 + p/100)(1 − (p − 5)/100). Set this equal to 1.02N and cancel N.
- Multiply by 10,000: (100 + p)(105 − p) = 10,200.
- Expand and rearrange: 10,500 + 5p − p² = 10,200, so p² − 5p − 300 = 0.
- Factor: (p − 20)(p + 15) = 0. Since p > 5, p = 20.
- Verify independently using an initial count of 100 plants: a 20% increase gives 120 plants, and a 15% decrease then gives 120 × 0.85 = 102 plants, exactly 2% above the initial count.
With Desmos
The graph shows why there are two algebraic candidates and why the context still matters.
Copy and paste each line into a separate expression:
y=(1+x/100)(1-(x-5)/100)y=1.02Set x from -25 to 30 and y from 0.9 to 1.1 so both crossings are visible.
The graphs meet at x = -15 and x = 20. The condition p > 5 leaves p = 20. Verify: 1.20 × 0.85 = 1.02.
Open the SAT Desmos calculator ↗Why this approach works
A percentage change multiplies the current amount. April starts with March’s increased total, so the two factors multiply; adding or subtracting the percentages would use the wrong starting amount.
After canceling the initial count, the expression gives final amount divided by initial amount for each possible percentage x. A final ratio of 1.02 means 102% of the original amount. The horizontal line y = 1.02 therefore asks which percentages produce exactly that ratio.
At each crossing, both expressions have the same output, so that x solves the original equation. Desmos finds candidates; the condition p > 5 chooses the valid one. The x-coordinate is the percentage, while the y-coordinate is a ratio.